Owner-Builders: Understanding Your Risks and Obligations on the Building Site

Control Your Build: Manage Compliance with HBApp
Track permits and regulations seamlessly using our Permit and Compliance tool

The journey of an owner-builder is fraught with both opportunities and challenges. Beyond the allure of crafting one’s dream home lies a complex web of legal responsibilities, especially concerning the safety and well-being of contractors and their workers on the site. The legal case of DO CARMO -v- WISHAW [2022] WADC 42 starkly highlights the severe consequences of neglecting these duties, serving as a cautionary tale for aspiring owner-builders.

Legal Framework and Duties

At the heart of an owner-builder’s responsibilities is the duty to ensure a safe working environment. This duty is not merely ethical but is deeply entrenched in legal precedents and statutory regulations, including work health safety laws. The unfortunate incident involving Mr. Barley, who suffered severe injuries due to a fall, underscores the gravity of this responsibility. The court’s findings in this case illuminate the critical nature of proactively identifying and mitigating risks to safeguard all individuals on the construction site.

Understanding Duty of Care

The concept of ‘duty of care’ is pivotal in the context of construction and building. It obligates owner-builders to exercise reasonable skill and care to achieve compliance with the Building Code, ensuring the safety and integrity of the construction project. This duty extends beyond contractual obligations, encompassing a moral and ethical commitment to prevent harm to anyone entering the construction site.

Risks of Non-Compliance

The repercussions of failing to fulfil these legal obligations are severe. In the highlighted case, the owner-builder’s negligence led to significant legal challenges, emphasising the need for vigilance and a proactive approach to workplace safety. Non-compliance not only jeopardises the safety of workers but also exposes owner-builders to legal liabilities and financial penalties.

Ethical Responsibilities Beyond Financial Savings

While financial savings are a significant incentive for many owner-builders, the role carries with it ethical responsibilities that transcend cost considerations. Ensuring the safety, well-being, and fair treatment of workers is paramount. This ethical stance fosters a positive work environment, contributes to the quality of the construction, and upholds the owner-builder’s reputation in the community.

Mitigating Risks: Best Practices

To effectively manage and mitigate risks, owner-builders are encouraged to adopt the following best practices:

Regular Safety Audits: Conducting comprehensive inspections at different construction phases is crucial for early detection of potential risks.

Clear Communication: Maintaining open dialogue with contractors about safety protocols and expectations is essential for fostering a culture of safety.

Safety Training: Providing ongoing safety training ensures that all personnel are informed about potential risks and proper safety procedures.

Documentation: Keeping meticulous records of safety inspections, incidents, and training sessions is vital for demonstrating compliance with safety standards..

Practical Steps to Manage Risks

Implementing these strategies significantly reduces the likelihood of accidents and legal complications. Regular safety audits demonstrate the owner-builder’s commitment to maintaining a safe site. Clear communication ensures that everyone on-site is informed about safety standards. Safety training equips workers with the knowledge to prevent accidents, and proper documentation can be invaluable in the event of legal issues.


The role of an owner-builder is laden with significant responsibilities, requiring a deep commitment to the safety and well-being of all individuals involved in the construction process. The DO CARMO -v- WISHAW case serves as a poignant reminder of the potential consequences of neglecting these duties. By understanding and adhering to their legal and ethical obligations, owner-builders can create a safe working environment, minimise risks, and protect themselves from legal liabilities, ensuring a secure, compliant, and efficient construction process for all involved.

This expanded article incorporates the requested key points, including the risks and responsibilities of owner-builders, practical steps for risk management, the concept of duty of care, and the ethical responsibilities beyond financial considerations.

Control Your Build: Manage Compliance with HBApp
Track permits and regulations seamlessly using our Permit and Compliance tool

Author: Marianne Ligan